Debate: Rules and Structure

Rules:

• Only one person speaks at a time.
• Do not interrupt each other.
• You must support your arguments with facts and logic. If possible, cite your sources.
  • If I think that your evidence is incorrect or fake, then I will take points from you.
• Do not insult or disrespect each other.
• Everyone must speak at least once during the debate. If you do not speak, you are défaillant.e.

Debate Structure

Part One: Argument Construction

Each team will share their main arguments. Each team should have between three and five distinct arguments. Each argument should be supported by a fact or a logical reason.

Team A: 5 to 7 minutes

Team B: 5 to 7 minutes

Note: While one team is speaking, the other team should take notes so that they can ask questions during cross-examination.

Break: 5 minutes to prepare questions for cross-examination

Part Two: Cross-Examination

Each team will have the opportunity to ask the other team questions about their argument. The responses of each team can and should be used against them, if possible.

Team A: 5 minutes of asking questions

Team B: 5 minutes of asking questions

Break: 5 minutes to prepare rebuttals

Part 3: Rebuttals

Each team will respond to the arguments of their opponents. Each team should also point out problems with the logic of their opponents and problems that they heard during cross-examination.

Team A: 5 minutes

Team B: 5 minutes

Break: 5 minutes to prepare for final arguments

Part Four: Final Arguments

Each team will briefly sum up the most important reason(s) that they are right and that their opponents are wrong.

Team A: 2 minutes

Team B: 2 minutes